On Sunday 10 May 2009 21:34:35 AAron Walters wrote:
As for the conflicting information, do you believe
that the information
presented by Volatility is incorrect or incomplete? Or are you wondering
why the other tools are not enumerating the information you seek?
AAron,
I don't believe that any of the information presented by any of the tools
is incorrect. I was just hoping to start a conversation about the
differences in the outputs that I have seen recent so that these difference
are pointed out and understood better. Brendran Dolan-Gavitt posted a
comment to the blog post that hits the nail on the head for me and, in a way,
confirmed my thoughts on what was happening.
As I pointed out in the post, I think these output differences just come
from different needs during the different phases of development of each tool.
The people who mainly use Audit Viewer or Responder many not have even been
concerned with "freed" connections. But obviously whoever wrote the
connscan2 plugin for Vol had a need at one point. As I was analyzing memory
from several OS types it would have been nice to have that functionality in
the other two tools since I was looking for that type of information.
I am very pleased about the conversation this post has generated and I hope
it is helping others, new to memory analysis like myself, understand the
functionality and differences between the tools. As the developers of each
tool understand the inner details of memory much better than I do I hope that
this helps get the ball rolling on some more collaboration and development in
all the products. We are only going to need these tools more in the future.
Thus far people from all three development teams have been very helpful and
professional.
Keep up the great work everybody.
Don
--
--------------------------
Don C. Weber
Information Security Consultant
Cutaway Security
CISSP, GIAC
#########################################
Website:
http://www.cutawaysecurity.com